The debate surrounding the 2026 Super Bowl halftime show continues to heat up as a petition calling for Bad Bunny’s replacement with George Strait has crossed 50,000 signatures on Change.org.
The campaign, organized under the name “Kar Shell,” urges the National Football League (NFL) and Roc Nation, which produces the halftime show, to reconsider their decision to feature the Puerto Rican superstar. The petition argues that Bad Bunny does not “honor American culture” or “unite our country,” claiming instead that the halftime show should celebrate the “roots of American music.”
“Halftime shows have leaned increasingly toward modern pop and international artists,” the petition reads. “It’s pivotal to remember the roots that have made American music what it is today.”
Cultural Clash Over America’s Biggest Stage
The controversy erupted shortly after several Trump-aligned politicians criticized the choice of Bad Bunny, whose upcoming performance marks a milestone for Latin artists on one of the world’s most-watched stages. In response, Bad Bunny—known for his sharp wit—remarked that English-speaking fans have “four months to learn Spanish” before the show.
The Puerto Rican rapper and global icon, born Benito Antonio Martínez Ocasio, has built a career blending reggaeton, Latin trap, and rap, becoming one of Spotify’s most streamed artists with nearly 50 million Instagram followers. His international influence, however, hasn’t shielded him from backlash among conservative circles who see his performances—often featuring drag elements and flamboyant fashion—as culturally divisive.
Meanwhile, the petition’s supporters are championing George Strait, a country music legend with more than 60 No. 1 singles across his four-decade career. Although Strait has been less active in recent years, his supporters describe him as an artist who “embodies the heart and soul of American music” and resonates across generations.
“George Strait represents unity, tradition, and timeless American music that truly deserves the 2026 Super Bowl spotlight,” the petition declares.
Political Undertones and Backlash
The controversy took a political turn when Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem reportedly said she would consider sending ICE agents to the halftime show. Her comments drew widespread criticism, given that Bad Bunny is an American citizen, born in the U.S. territory of Puerto Rico.
Bad Bunny has previously spoken about his concerns regarding immigration enforcement, revealing he avoided certain U.S. tour stops for fear that “ICE could be outside [his concerts].”
While opposition to his performance has gained traction online, Bad Bunny also enjoys strong support within the entertainment industry. Jennifer Lopez, who performed with him during the 2020 Super Bowl halftime show alongside Shakira, defended him on CBS Mornings.
“Music and art transcend language,” Lopez said. “It doesn’t matter where you’re from. He’s done that probably more than anybody of any generation.”
Despite the growing petition, few believe it poses any real threat to Bad Bunny’s appearance. Last year’s Super Bowl halftime show drew over 127 million viewers, suggesting that the pop star’s upcoming performance will remain one of the most anticipated cultural events of 2026.
